top of page

Laminate Isn’t Cheaper If You Have to Replace It Twice

  • Writer: Jennifer Alvarez
    Jennifer Alvarez
  • Dec 2
  • 3 min read

Most conversations about “laminate” today are really about LVP. It’s waterproof, inexpensive, and easy to source. Published lifespan charts often show LVP lasting 15–25 years, which puts it in the same theoretical range as engineered wood and wood-veneer products.


But those numbers assume ideal conditions: low traffic, consistent temperatures, balanced HVAC, no direct sunlight, and no rolling loads.


Commercial spaces don’t live in those conditions.


The gap between published lifespan and practical lifespan is where the cost difference shows up — and it’s where a real-wood veneer over a high-density core delivers more value per year than LVP.


ree

1. Published Lifespans Are Similar — Real-World Outcomes Aren’t


Trade-level sources consistently point out that vinyl’s lifespan depends heavily on usage conditions and the quality of the wear layer. The moment the wear layer loses clarity, the floor reaches the end of its service life — because vinyl cannot be refinished.


In commercial traffic, wear-layer haze, scuffing, and pattern degradation often happen long before the warranty term.


That’s the first break between theory and reality.


2. LVP Loses Its Visual Quality Long Before It Fails Structurally


Industry guides note that LVP’s decorative pattern is a printed film. Once the wear layer dulls or abrades, the floor can look tired even if the planks are technically intact.


Common long-term issues documented by inspectors and commercial flooring specialists include:


  • Surface hazing from repeated cleanings

  • Traffic lanes forming “shiny paths”

  • Printed patterns fading or flattening

  • Texture wearing down in high-use areas


Wood veneer doesn’t rely on printed visuals. Real wood ages more gracefully, even as the space around it evolves.


Maison Plank’s Titanium Ultra finish adds to that stability. It resists the surface haze and clarity loss that often accelerates LVP’s end-of-life timeline.


3. Heat, Sunlight, and Subfloor Conditions Affect PVC Over Time


Multiple trade resources highlight that vinyl products expand and contract with temperature shifts and can deform when exposed to direct sunlight or warm subfloors.


The effects show up in:


  • Cupping of individual planks

  • Curling near windows

  • Seam separation in colder cycles

  • Movement over irregular subfloors


A dense, recovered-wood HDF core doesn’t behave like PVC. It remains stable and flat, which supports a longer usable life in mixed conditions.


4. Repairs Are Technically Possible — Visually Difficult


Sources agree on this point: LVP is replaceable plank-by-plank, but the match is rarely perfect.


UV exposure, traffic, and cleaning patterns age each board differently. Replacements stand out because the sheen and tone no longer match the surrounding area.


Wood veneer has natural variation and depth, which helps minimize “patch” visibility. And Maison Plank’s finish doesn’t get hazy or show cloudy tones over time. The surface stays consistent.


5. Premium LVP Isn’t Cheap — and It Still Ages Like Vinyl


Trade pricing breakdowns show that thicker planks, thicker wear layers, and stiffer rigid cores all increase the cost of LVP. “Entry-level” vinyl is inexpensive; commercial-grade LVP is not.


That closes the pricing gap with wood veneer — while the visual gap remains wide. Real wood stays timeless. Printed patterns follow trends.


6. Replacement Costs Hit Far Harder Than Material Costs


Material cost is just the starting number. The real expense is in the things that don’t show up on spec sheets:


  • Labor

  • Downtime

  • Tenant disruption

  • Lost revenue from closed rooms or corridors

  • Site protection and re-routing


Spaces rarely replace floors because they “failed.” They replace them because they no longer look acceptable.


When a floor looks good longer, budgets stay predictable longer.


Final Thought


Published lifespan charts make LVP and wood-veneer flooring look similar on paper. In real commercial environments, they perform very differently.


LVP’s lifecycle ends when the wear layer clouds or the pattern breaks down — long before it reaches the end of its structural lifespan. Wood veneer maintains clarity, depth, and visual longevity, giving projects a longer, more stable service life without the recurring costs of early replacement.


Maison Plank gives you that longevity with a dense, stable core and a finish built for clarity and durability — with a real wood wear layer to carry the aesthetic.




bottom of page